Share your thoughts, delights, criticisms, and describe your face when

spoiler

the musical number kicked in.

Please honor Bill and Ted’s Law: Be excellent to each other.

  • Dharma Curious@startrek.websiteEnglish
    1·
    11 months ago

    So, I rarely like a doctor for the first several episodes, my brain can’t get past the last doctor. Took me forever with Smith. I always end up rewatching them later and loving them, it’s just that I can’t handle the sudden differentness well.

    All that said, I really freaking enjoyed this one. I’m not fully in love with Ncuti yet, but I did really enjoy the episode, and LOVED the song. Oddly, the only Doctor I loved first off was Jodi. Ncuti is closer than most, though.

    Also. That kilt. Meow.

    Also loving the new sonic.

    ETA

    Forgot to mention, Ruby really reminds me of Clara in the best way.

    • CeruleanRuin@lemmings.worldEnglish
      0·
      11 months ago

      The only thing about the song was I couldn’t get my head around the logic of it. I know logic is usually pretty far off in RTD’s stories, but it usually at least pretends there a reason for things that happen. Unless I missed it, there wasn’t even a word of dialogue about the singing.

      • Dharma Curious@startrek.websiteEnglish
        1·
        11 months ago

        I think the logic was that the goblins were singing, like, as part of their culture. Not like Musical logic, but more like how some cultures pray in song, or some cultures chant. Goblins sing big numbers as a way of worshipping/venerating the goblin king, or perhaps it’s similar to how Christians say grace before a meal. Gotta sing for your dinner. The doctor and Ruby just took advantage of that aspect of their culture and Bugs Bunny’d their way outta there.

    • Value Subtracted@startrek.websiteEnglish
      1·
      11 months ago

      I’m not going to speculate as to her precise identity, but if we take everything the episode showed us at face value:

      • She knows what a TARDIS is.

      • She did not recognize the Doctor’s police box as a TARDIS until he dematerialized it in front of her, and even then did not seem to know who the Doctor was.

      Again, if we are to take all this at face value, I think that narrows the list of candidates significantly, and rules out most, if not all, “familiar” characters.

      Could she be a former companion of a pre-Hartnell Doctor? I know the Fugitive Doctor’s TARDIS appeared as a police box to Thirteen, but it’s very possible the chameleon circuit was operational in those days.